The Hidden Problem of Social Security – It’s Not the Cuts

Concerns are growing among retirees about potential Social Security benefit cuts, driven by fears that the trust funds may run out of money to cover the monthly benefits for over 70 million beneficiaries in the U.S. This financial strain is largely due to the mass retirement of older workers, leading to a revenue shortfall since payroll taxes are the primary income source for Social Security. However, there’s a more pressing yet lesser-known issue that the Social Security Administration (SSA) is grappling with.

COLA

Every year, Social Security benefits are adjusted based on the cost of living adjustment (COLA) to help beneficiaries maintain their purchasing power as living expenses rise. However, seniors have consistently received inadequate COLAs for many years. According to a 2023 study by the Senior Citizens League, the purchasing power of Social Security recipients has declined by 36% since 2000. This decline is largely due to the flawed method of calculating COLAs.

CPI-W

The SSA uses the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers (CPI-W) to determine COLAs. Benefits increase when the CPI-W rises year over year but remain unchanged if it doesn’t. The problem is that the CPI-W doesn’t accurately reflect the expenses faced by seniors. Retired Americans, for instance, spend more on healthcare compared to younger individuals. The CPI-W fails to account for these higher healthcare costs, unlike the Consumer Price Index for the Elderly (CPI-E), which better represents senior-specific expenses. Despite advocates pushing for the adoption of the CPI-E for COLA calculations, progress has been slow.

Savings

Estimates for the 2025 Social Security COLA range from 2.6% to 3%, significantly lower than the 3.2% adjustment for 2024. Many seniors worry about the small increase they might receive next year. Relying solely on Social Security COLAs is unwise due to their inherent flaws. If you’re still working, it’s crucial to save as much as possible to supplement your Social Security benefits upon retirement.

Legislative efforts should aim to make Social Security COLAs more equitable. However, with the impending issue of benefit reductions as trust funds dwindle, lawmakers might prioritize this over COLA adjustments. Hence, it falls upon individuals to ensure they have enough savings to compensate for inadequate COLA increases.

Impact of a 3% COLA

While the inflation rate has stabilized, it remains above pre-pandemic levels by 1%. In 2024, inflation rose from 3.1% in January to 3.5% in March, sparking hopes for a higher COLA. However, the cost of living for seniors increased significantly from April to May, hitting 3.3%, which could set the trend for the next few months and influence future adjustments. The Senior Citizens League estimates a 2025 COLA between 2.57% and 3%. A 3% COLA could result in a noticeable increase in monthly payments for seniors.

Retirement Age	Monthly Average	Monthly Check (Plus 3% COLA)
Average Payment	$1,900	$1,957
Claim Benefits at 62	$2,710	$2,791
Claim Benefits at 67	$3,822	$3,937
Claim Benefits at 70	$4,873	$5,019

These adjustments highlight the necessity for seniors to plan and save adequately to manage their living expenses better and maintain their quality of life.

Social Security faces numerous challenges, from trust fund shortages to inadequate COLAs. While legislative action is essential, individuals must also take proactive steps to secure their financial future. Building a substantial nest egg can provide the necessary cushion against insufficient Social Security adjustments, ensuring a more comfortable retirement.

FAQs