3 Major Social Security Changes Coming for Millions of Retirees in 2025 – New Payments

Social Security is a crucial source of income for millions of retirees in the United States. In fact, as of April 2024, over 50 million retirees rely on Social Security benefits, with 60% of them considering it their primary source of income. However, many Americans hold misconceptions about how Social Security works, and upcoming changes in 2025 might catch some by surprise. Knowing these changes is essential for current and future beneficiaries. Let’s investigate three major changes expected in 2025.

Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA)

One of the biggest misconceptions about Social Security is that it isn’t protected against inflation. A survey by the Nationwide Retirement Institute found that 70% of adults incorrectly believed this. In reality, Social Security benefits receive an annual Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA) to help maintain purchasing power. The COLA is determined by the changes in the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers (CPI-W) during the third quarter of the previous year.

For 2025, the official COLA won’t be determined until mid-October when the September CPI-W data is released. However, based on current inflation trends, The Senior Citizens League estimates a 2.7% increase in benefits. This estimate has been adjusted upward due to recent inflation spikes, and the final COLA could be even higher.

Assuming the 2.7% estimate holds, the average monthly benefit for retired workers would increase by about $51, bringing the average benefit to $1,967. While this increase provides some relief, many beneficiaries may feel it doesn’t fully keep pace with rising living costs, particularly given the volatility in inflation rates.

Social Security Taxes

Another common misconception is that workers pay Social Security taxes on all of their income. In reality, there is a cap on the amount of earnings subject to Social Security payroll taxes. For 2024, this cap is $168,600, meaning income above this amount isn’t taxed for Social Security purposes. However, this limit is adjusted annually based on the national average wage index, and it’s expected to rise in 2025.

The Social Security Board of Trustees projects that the maximum taxable earnings limit will increase to $174,900 in 2025. This means that workers earning above this threshold could see an increase in their Social Security taxes. Specifically, at the current 6.2% tax rate, a worker earning more than $174,900 would pay $10,844 in Social Security taxes in 2025, compared to $10,453 in 2024, reflecting a $391 increase.

This adjustment is important for high earners to consider, as it will impact their take-home pay. While it might seem like a small amount, these incremental increases can add up over time, especially when combined with other potential tax changes.

Benefit

The Nationwide survey also found confusion regarding the retirement earnings test, with 46% of adults not knowing that some Social Security benefits may be withheld if they work before reaching full retirement age (FRA). This rule applies to beneficiaries who earn above certain income limits before FRA.

In 2024, the lower earnings limit for those under FRA is $22,320, and the upper limit for those who reach FRA during the year is $59,520. For every $2 earned above the lower limit, $1 is withheld from Social Security benefits. For those reaching FRA, $1 is withheld for every $3 earned above the upper limit.

In 2025, these limits are expected to increase, with preliminary estimates suggesting that the lower limit will rise to $23,280 and the upper limit to $61,800. This means beneficiaries will be able to earn more before their benefits are reduced. Importantly, any benefits withheld before reaching FRA are not permanently lost; they are gradually repaid over time, allowing retirees to recover the withheld amounts during their lifetime.

These upcoming changes underscore the importance of staying informed about Social Security rules. Misunderstanding or overlooking these adjustments can lead to financial surprises, but with careful planning, beneficiaries can make the most of their Social Security benefits.

FAQs